What’s the big deal about “enthusiastic” consent?
A blog by Irregular Jenn Wilson – December 2024
Sexual consent is mostly taught in terms of a gatekeeper model. Someone (usually a man) has to get consent from someone else (usually a woman) in order to be permitted access to sex.
Whilst this may seem better than no consent education at all, it’s highly problematic. It underlines an idea that has become a cultural standard – one that #MeToo shone a spotlight on – the idea that men are sexually predatory and that women must protect themselves from becoming victims. This idea, and this framing of consent, is problematic. It suggests that women don’t experience any sexual desire at all. It’s nonsense for anyone under the LGBTQIA+ umbrella – because it’s an idea based on rigid definitions of binary gender and heterosexuality.
It also frames consent as a one-off transaction – like a tick box on a form requiring consent to terms and conditions (that few of us read) – or an opt out from subscribing to a mailing list. Still, you can always unsubscribe, right? Defining consent as a simple, one-off transaction is a massive oversimplification of how consent works in practice. When we are exploring the possibilities of how we might connect, sexually, romantically (or in other ways as unique and diverse humans) it can often be a complex, ongoing navigation towards finding common ground.
My working definition is: “Consent is a practice for connection, whereby everyone involved or directly impacted by it is comfortable enough and secure enough to continue.”
By this definition, not all consensual sex is enthusiastic. The principle that if you’re not having fun (or your partner doesn’t seem to be enjoying it) you should stop has it’s uses, of course. A lack of enthusiasm might be a helpful indicator that whatever was happening sexually between you is no longer wanted, or agreed to – especially if there was enthusiasm and now it’s stopped. Sexual consent doesn’t always look like enthusiasm, though.
Sometimes consensual sex is comforting, gentle, quiet or sensual. Sometimes it might be a bit routine, or perhaps functional – ‘trying’ for a baby, for example, can take a lot of the fun out of it. Then there’s BDSM and kink – where perhaps someone’s fully consensual, intense enjoyment might look like quite the opposite. In consensual kink, the partners involved communicate to establish trust and understanding before, during and after a ‘scene’, taking care that all involved know exactly what is and isn’t OK. Most of the experienced kinksters I’ve met have a pretty nuanced understanding of consent – misunderstandings around things like pain, physical restraint or power play can lead to extreme harm.
It was a sex worker that first challenged me directly on the concept of ‘enthusiastic’ consent – they said that it’s a job and like any other profession, there are days when work is a bit of a chore – and yet you still choose to turn up and do the work, because that’s how you’ve decided to earn a living.
Also, enthusiasm can be faked – if you’ve watched that infamous scene in the film “When Harry Met Sally” where, to prove this very point, Meg Ryan loudly fakes an orgasm in the middle of a crowded restaurant, you’ll know what I mean.
However, if you’re feeling pressured or obligated into sex, whilst the law would probably not recognise it as “assault” or “rape”, it might well not be genuine consent.
Are you comfortable with what you’re doing? Do you feel safe, secure and comfortable enough to say ‘No’ (or more likely, say something like ‘Stop’ or ‘Hang on a minute’ or find some other way of communicating that you’d rather not right now)?
Several of my favourite consent educators say, “If you can’t say ‘No’ then you can’t say ‘Yes’ either.” I think that’s a pretty good starting point for working out whether you are inside or outside of consent. You can’t consent meaningfully if you’re too fearful or embarrassed to speak up…, or you just don’t understand that by not clearly communicating the word ‘No’ your ‘Yes’ is assumed…, or you don’t entirely understand what you’re consenting to…
Another way to recognise these nuances is by looking at consent in other contexts. For example, how relevant is ‘enthusiastic’ consent when it comes to those online tick boxes, or medical consent? I, for one, have never felt enthusiastic about receiving dental treatment – I fully consent, but it’s certainly not a pleasure.
Over-simplifying consent as just a one-off tick box where ‘yes means yes, no means no’ can be dangerous. Checking ‘unsubscribe’ is a fairly simple process if you join a mailing list and then regret it – but when you’ve agreed (or appeared to agree) to something as physically, mentally and emotionally as complex as personal connection, unravelling those agreements can be tricky. When it comes to sex, if you’ve demonstrated by your apparent ‘enthusiasm’ that you’re up for it, then telling your partner that you’ve changed your mind is probably going to be harder than it would have been to refuse in the first place.
Some sex educators have come up with checklists designed to work through the complexities of sexual consent, like Planned Parenthood’s model ‘Consent with FRIES’, an acronym that says that consensual sex is: Freely Given – Reversible – Informed – Enthusiastic – Specific
These may be helpful ideas to bear in mind, but no checklist allows for the intricacies of relating and connecting as human beings. Every one of the ideas in FRIES has the potential for misunderstanding and harm. For example, is consent ‘Freely Given’ if one party has any kind of power over the other? Harvey Weinstein’s ‘casting couch’ is just one example where that power imbalance is obvious, but it isn’t always that clear cut. Imbalance could be an age, gender or other obvious gap, or the social capital of being seen as some kind of leader, expert or cool kid. Power and fear can impact on consent even when one person just has a feeling that saying ‘No’ might not be safe. How is your freedom to consent affected, or your apparent displays of enthusiasm, if alcohol or drugs are involved? Once you’re in their house, or their bed, can you freely change your mind? Even “Informed” consent has nuances. How can you truly consent if you don’t know what you don’t know?
If we stop seeing consent as an obstacle to one person getting what they want from another, then we can start to see consent as the goal in itself. Surely what any of us wants is consensual connection – a shared experience that everyone involved is genuinely willing to take part in, and nobody is tolerating something that they don’t want through fear, or feeling upset or regretful.
Once we see consent as this nuanced practice for navigating human connection, it can become liberating. When connections are based on trust, openness, honesty and understanding, then wider possibilities open up. As I tell my clients, the thing about being able to say and hear “No” is it makes your “Yes” way more ‘yessy’.
I think it’s important to remember the issues we have with consent are systemic. I was asked by a journalist why, 7 years on, #MeToo hasn’t changed things – and answered that it’s because #MeToo couldn’t bring about systemic change – if it had, perhaps the United States wouldn’t have elected a known rapist as President.
In the immediate wake of #MeToo we saw a backlash or counter-argument of #MenToo… not dissimilar from the way #AllLivesMatter is used to undermine the power of the #BlackLivesMatter message. The trauma and stigma experienced by male victims of sexual violence is not OK – but nor is it a counter-argument for addressing the systemic problem of violence against women and girls (and people of other systemically stigmatised genders.). And that’s before we even begin to consider intersectionality.
Gender-based sexual violence is pretty much inevitable because for generations we’ve built our social systems and cultural standards on the binary categorisation of men as, by nature, sexual predators and women as ‘the weaker sex’, biologically bound to be victims. There’s plenty of evidence to suggest this dichotomy is false, but #MeToo didn’t fundamentally challenge this cultural belief about human behaviour. It did a powerful and important job of highlighting the scale of the problems that come from it – and #MeToo was, and still is, a call to all of us to do better.
Sadly the word ‘consent’ has been so strongly associated only with sexual consent that I find that my use of the word is often greeted with eye-rolling, sniggering and an assumption that I’m about to express moral outrage at the idea of anyone having an enjoyable sex life.
I’m not.
Shame and blame won’t solve the root problem – they push us apart into us and them, perpetrator and victim, driving us away from consensual connection. Practicing consent meaningfully requires openness and curiosity, a willingness to ask for what you want, and to hear ‘No’, or ‘Yes’, or all the subtle spoken and unspoken nuances in between. Finger wagging and prudishness get in the way of that potential for connection.
We can allow ourselves to conform to rigid gender roles and outmoded stereotypes, excuse harm with trite expressions, like “boys will be boys” and “locker room banter”, and wield consent as a blunt (and ineffective) instrument of the law, upholding the systems that blame or victimise us.
Or we can practice using our consent in all our interactions and connections, and start to reshape our culture around it. I invite you to notice those times you’re doing something you feel you ‘should’ but don’t want to, and draw a line. Or those times you want to act but it feels too rebellious. There are lots of everyday opportunities to practice consent. You could try turning down an invitation to something you probably won’t enjoy; refuse to answer a personal question or share your opinion; say “no” to a favour and take some time to rest; resist the pressure to conform and hide, and actually show up fully as yourself.
Practicing using your agency in lower risk situations means that if or when it comes to sex, you’re more likely to feel more confident in your abilities to ask for what you want, communicate what you don’t, and find ways to be together that feel good for all involved.
For anyone who’s spent a lifetime conforming to expectations, these small acts can feel radical and liberatory. Consent can be harnessed as a tool for social change. Each person that decides to show up with more integrity and authenticity, to challenge their own or someone else’s limiting cultural beliefs, break down standard assumptions – and instead model something kinder and more consensual, something that seeks common ground instead of cercion – takes us one step closer to the change we’d all like to see in the world.
I’m very enthusiastic about that.
© Jenn Wilson December 2025
Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to JENN WILSON and https://irregular.org.uk with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.