Nobody wins the gender war

If you’re a feminist, 

  • or someone who cares about the rights of women and girls, 
  • or someone who recognises sexism and misogyny and gender-based violence are BIG social issues that need tackling 
  • or someone who cares about safer spaces 
  • or human rights 
  • or equity and fairness and justice…

… if you’re any of those things and you think that today’s UK Supreme Court ruling is some kind of “victory”, please be careful…

(For context, I’ve been a feminist my whole life, I’m female, I’ve birthed 2 children and I’m going through menopause, I use they/them pronouns and no longer identify fully as a “woman”… if I had to wear a label it would be “genderqueer”… and none of that is important.) 

Regardless of my gender or my sex or my body shape or skin colour or height or the way I dress or the way I love or the people I find attractive, THIS IS NOT A VICTORY TO CELEBRATE.

When one side wins and another loses, I’m not sure it’s something any of us ought to celebrate… whatever my position in any battleground, I wonder… what happens to the losers? What happens when we celebrate their loss? 

The only victory I can celebrate wholeheartedly is one that makes the world kinder, safer and fairer for all of us… and that is not what’s happened today. 

What happened today is a legal landmark.

The ruling states that current UK law should be enacted based on the principle that gender (man/woman) is based on biological sex (male/female). That might sound like common sense to some… there’s perhaps some truth to it, but it’s both ambiguous and a huge over simplification of human diversity.

The ruling also states that trans women still have a legal right to claim sex-based discrimination – as well as discrimination based on gender reassignment – because living as a woman and looking like a woman means experiencing sexism… regardless of what body parts, chromosomes or gametes you have… 

But those who are celebrating a victory today aren’t saying anything about that. 

And those of us who are fearful of what the ruling implies are painfully aware of bias in reporting, and the impact of that in the court of public opinion.

What this ruling does is uphold a longstanding, common belief that the physical sex characteristics of human beings fit neatly into two boxes, and that those two boxes determine something fundamental about our identity. 

The gender critical feminist lobby are celebrating the idea that “biology is immutable.” I don’t think biological determinism helps women at all.

When we allow our very sense of who we are… what we can do, who we can become… to be determined by our “biology” – our physical anatomy as observed at birth – and to be put into one of two boxes that we can never escape, nobody “won”. 

I don’t think women benefit from allowing themselves to be defined as the weaker sex, inevitable victims to be preyed on by “biologically” stronger, predatory males. We are all capable of SO much more, and we are almost infinitely more complex – physically, psychologically and socially – than that. 

If we believe human beings can and do rise above our baser instincts, to realise possibilities that are beyond standard expectations and assumptions of “normal”, then how is it any kind of victory to box ourselves in to binary, limited labels that harm almost all of us? This is not liberation.

The only winners today are those privileged few that benefit from having ordinary people argue about this stuff and blame a tiny section of the population for all that is wrong, rather than tackle the real issues that matter – like wealth inequality and climate change.

If you celebrate today, you’re celebrating with a handful of billionaires who do not care at all about women’s safety. 

I prefer to believe that we are all capable of more, that empathy matters more than hollow victory, that love and hope are more powerful than hate and fear. 

© Jenn Wilson 16 April 2025

Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to JENN WILSON and https://irregular.org.uk with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.


Posted

in

,

by